DebtDrop Get the app

Student Loan Payoff Plan: Snowball or Avalanche?

Student loans often come as several loans at different rates. Which one should get your extra payment? Here is a worked example with three loans, plus the questions to ask before you pick.

The example

Three loans, $23,000 in total, with $259 in minimum payments:

LoanBalanceAPRMinimum
Loan A$4,5005%$48
Loan B$11,0006%$122
Loan C$7,5007.5%$89

Loan A is the smallest balance (snowball target). Loan C has the highest rate (avalanche target). That is the situation where the methods really differ.

The results

PlanDebt-free inTotal interestFirst loan gone
Minimum payments only120 months$8,063–
+$100 a month, snowball79 months$5,215Month 33
+$100 a month, avalanche78 months$4,848Month 46

An extra $100 a month saves about $3,215 in interest and 42 months versus minimums only. Avalanche beats snowball by $366 in interest. Because the rates are close together (5–7.5%), the method matters less than the extra payment.

How much does the extra payment change it?

Extra per monthDebt-free inTotal interest (avalanche)
Minimums only120 months$8,063
+$5094 months$6,012
+$10078 months$4,848
+$20058 months$3,525

Questions to ask first

  • Is the loan federal or private? Federal loans can have income-driven plans, deferment and forgiveness options that private loans lack. Paying one off early gives those up. Check before you accelerate.
  • Does the loan have a prepayment penalty? Most do not, but check the terms.
  • Is the extra applied to principal? Tell your servicer to apply extra payments to the loan you chose, not to future installments.
  • Do you have an emergency buffer? Low-rate loans are often a lower priority than a high-APR card.

A simple way to decide

  • Rates within a point or two: pick the method that keeps you motivated.
  • One loan much higher than the rest: avalanche saves more.
  • Many small loans: snowball clears accounts and reduces paperwork.

Use the calculator to enter your loans and compare both orders, or add them to DebtDrop for reminders and a date. This is a planning illustration, not financial advice.

FAQ

Should I pay off student loans early?

It depends on the rate, federal protections you would give up and your other debts. Higher-rate debts usually come first. This is not financial advice.

Does paying extra reduce my monthly payment?

Usually extra payments shorten the term rather than lower the monthly payment, unless your servicer recasts the loan. Check with them.

Which loan should I pay first with avalanche?

The one with the highest interest rate, regardless of balance.

DebtDrop is a planning tool, not financial advice. Examples use APR ÷ 12 as the monthly rate and fixed payments; your lender’s figures can differ slightly.